Sandra Mansi (Eyewitness to Champ)
RIP (b: November 20, 1943 – d: March 31, 2018)
8.7 – Creatures of the Deep (9.4.15)
Early on the morning of Saturday, March 31, 2018, at Bristol, Vermont, Sandra Mansi, (born November 20, 1943), 74, passed away of cancer. Mansi was especially well-known in cryptozoology as the photographer of one of the Lake Champlain Monsters (“Champ”). Her picture has been declared one of the best pieces of evidence for Lake Monsters. She was an icon in the field. She will be missed.
On the warm summer day of July 5, 1977, Anthony and Sandra Mansi (who were engaged at the time) and her children were traveling by car from Vergennes to St. Albans, Vermont. They had spent the night with Sandra’s relatives near Vergennes, then drove along rural route 36, and stopped for a picnic at a lakeside field north of St. Albans.
Afterwards, as Mansi watched her children play in the water, she saw an object in the middle of the lake. At first, she thought it was a large fish, then perhaps the hand of a diver surfacing, but finally she realized it was the grayish brown head and long snakelike neck of a creature breaking the lake’s surface. Its head seemed to be twisting around, scanning the countryside, Mansi later told me (Loren Coleman) in an interview. The monster had a skin “like an eel,” she said, and was “slimy looking.” Although scared to death, she rushed to get her Kodak Instamatic camera from her car, and snapped one shot of Champ, before, as she put it, they “hightailed out of there.”
“We had trouble rationalizing it, so we decided to call it a 2,000-pound duck,” she told participants at the August 1981 Lake Champlain seminar where she decided to publicly reveal the details about her experience for the first time. “It’s easier to live with a 2,000-pound duck than something you don’t know.”
Fearful of the jokes and ridicule she might be subjected to outside her family, Mansi hid the picture for three years. Finally, encouraged by friends and the growing interest in Champ promoted by Zarzynski and his investigation, Mansi, by now living in Winchester, New Hampshire, produced the photograph for scrutiny by some academic types allegedly interested in the monster. The fact that Mansi had lost the negative, and had never known the exact location of the sighting, led to some difficult moments – until Mansi was introduced to Zarzynski.
Finally, encouraged by friends and the growing interest in Champ promoted by Joseph Zarzynski, a New York social studies teacher who was investigating reports of the Lake Champlain Monsters, Mansi, by now living in Winchester, New Hampshire, produced the photograph and held it up for scrutiny by academic researchers interested in the monster.
It was not a pleasant experience. Mansi suffered for months from nightmares, self-doubt and her fears of public ridicule. “It’s frightening,” she said, “and sometimes I wish I hadn’t told anyone about the picture, or I hadn’t seen the monster.” The fact that Mansi, following a divorce, relocations, and moves, had lost the negative by that time, and had never known the exact location of the sighting, led to some difficult moments, as her credibility was questioned.
But the experts now uniformly hold the photograph in high regard. Zarzynski calls it “the single most impressive piece of evidence” for Champ. University of Chicago biologist Roy Mackal, along with cryptozoologist J. Richard Greenwell of the Office of Arid Land Studies and photo analyst B. Roy Frieden of the Optical Sciences Center, both of the University of Arizona, examined Mansi’s photograph and subjected it to computer analysis. Frieden, a professor of optical sciences, found no evidence of a montage or superposition. Greenwell and Mackal were similarly convinced that Mansi had snapped a picture of an unknown animate object in the lake. In 1999, the skeptical producers of the PBS program NOVA would run more analyses, and claim the Mansi photograph was one of the few pieces of good evidence for an unknown animal in any lake in the world.
“I still have nightmares about the monster,” Sandra Mansi told me. “The thing is chasing me, and I’m running to get away. After I saw the monster and took his picture, I had the dreams all the time, but then I got in touch with Zarzynski and the nightmares went away for a while. Now, with all the public pressure and people saying I didn’t really see it, the dreams have started again. It’s frightening, and sometimes I wish I hadn’t told anyone about the picture, or I hadn’t seen the monster.”
Sandra Mansi, soft-spoken and matter-of-fact, had become an instant celebrity thanks to the New York Times and Time magazine. I spoke to her in late August of 1981, following a stimulating day at the first scientific seminar devoted to a study of the monster that has been reported lurking in the waters of Lake Champlain the past 300 years.
“I have been very careful about the people I tell about my experiences,” Mansi said. “Someone recently was amazed when I told them I was going to the seminar, and began asking me if I believed in ESP, UFOs, and the tooth fairy. I didn’t even tell that person I had seen and photographed the monster.”
Sandra Mansi moved on in her life, but the Monster in the picture turned out to be her legacy. Sure, there was family, work, and New England. But, alas, in the background, there always was Champ. And in her nightmares, the Monster. And her attempts to run away from something she never saw coming.
The “Does Champ Exist?” seminar took place on August 29, 1981, in Shelburne, Vermont.